The interview with Fabian Barth, VAT Manager at Alvarez & Marsal, discusses the challenges of obtaining binding rulings in the UK, recent Supreme Court VAT cases in 2025, and his view that legislative changes should allow public law arguments in tribunals. He notes that the Hotel La Tour and Prudential cases downplayed CJEU precedent, and that European case law remains binding but is not always applied.
Hotel La Tour [2025] UKSC 46 and Prudential [2025] UKSC 34 were the Supreme Court cases involving VAT in 2025.
Both Hotel La Tour and Prudential downplayed the role of CJEU case law in their decisions.
No, binding rulings are quite difficult to obtain in the UK.
He suggests legislative intervention to make it clear that public law arguments may always be entertained in tribunals, easing review of HMRC decisions.
Get VAT and indirect tax news delivered to your inbox twice a week.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Seeburger · about 7 hours ago
The UK will require all VAT invoices to be e‑invoiced by 2029, mandating machine‑readable formats and accredited transmission. The article outlines the scope, Peppol alignment, and a step‑by‑step timeline for 2026‑2028 to help finance, IT and procurement prepare. It highlights key milestones such as selecting an access point, adopting a canonical data model, and piloting with trading partners.
Deloitte · 2 days ago
The Finance (No. 2) Bill 2024‑26 has been amended in Committee and will return to the House of Commons for further stages. Scotland will introduce a new Air Departure Tax on 1 April 2027, replacing APD, with a consultation closing 26 March 2026. Deloitte’s Advance Tax Certainty service will become operational from July 2026, while the OECD Global Forum on VAT met in January 2026 to discuss digital economy and near real‑time data collection.
GOV.UK · 5 days ago
The HMRC internal manual outlines the rules and procedures for calculating and managing default interest on VAT arrears. It covers legal powers, calculation methods, interest adjustments, and circumstances affecting default interest, providing guidance for HMRC staff and taxpayers.
Bloomberg Tax · 7 days ago
The UK First‑Tier Tax Tribunal issued a judgment on 26 January 2026 clarifying the eligibility of input VAT deductions in cases involving fraud. The tribunal upheld HMRC’s denial of deductions for payments to four payroll service providers, finding that the taxpayers knew the transactions were connected to VAT fraud. The decision reinforces that knowledge of fraud can lead to denial of input VAT recovery.
Cooper Parry · 7 days ago
The UK First Tier Tribunal ruled that payments under VPAG, PPRS and similar schemes are post‑supply price reductions, meaning the VAT originally paid was too high. The Upper Tribunal hearing is set for 9–11 February 2026, with a decision expected shortly after, potentially unlocking up to £2.5 billion in VAT reclaims for pharma and healthcare businesses. Companies can adjust VAT back up to four years by filing protective claims now.
KPMG · 7 days ago
KPMG’s weekly update highlights two contrasting VAT rulings on hair loss treatments and a key import‑VAT recovery case. The UK Tax Tribunal zero‑rated the Kinsey system for female hair loss as a service of adapting goods for a disabled person, while a surgical hair transplant was standard‑rated as cosmetic. The Yourway Transport decision clarified that a taxpayer can recover import VAT on drugs moved to other Member States when acting as an agent and deemed owner under s47.
